Newcastle 0-1 Everton: Round 9’s lowest-rated contest
A scrappy 0-1 at Newcastle saw eight poor match ratings across the 22 players. Thierno Barry’s 49th-minute goal settled it for Everton.
Worst match · 2 Nov 2026 · St. James' Park
NewcastleNewcastle 0-1 Everton on Monday 2 November 2026 was the kind of match where the numbers do most of the talking. Across the 22 players rated, eight recorded poor match ratings, with an overall average of 6.79, and the contest never really escaped a low-grade feel despite a decent volume of attempts.
Everton’s 1-0 win came through a single moment after the break, and while the scoreline was tight, the underlying stats show why Newcastle left frustrated: 17 total shots and 52% possession, but only two shots on target.
One decisive spell after half-time
The only goal arrived on 49 minutes, when Thierno Barry finished to make it 0-1. With no assist recorded, it reads as a straightforward, clinical action in a match that otherwise lacked clean sequences in the final third.
Everton were the more threatening side in terms of quality. They edged big chances 3-2 and led expected goals (xG) 2.15 to 1.47, a notable gap in a one-goal game. They also hit the target five times from 16 shots, a far better conversion of territory into genuine work for the goalkeeper than Newcastle managed.
Newcastle’s discipline also unravelled at the end, with Jacob Ramsey sent off on 90 minutes for a second yellow. It did not change the result, but it underlined a night where control came and went.
Newcastle’s attackers couldn’t turn pressure into precision
The home side’s biggest issue was the mismatch between volume and accuracy. Seventeen shots for just two on target is a blunt return, and it is reflected in the lowest individual match ratings.
Harvey Barnes (5.5) and William Osula (5.8) both played 90 minutes but couldn’t provide the cutting edge Newcastle needed. Around them, the struggle was shared rather than isolated: Anthony Elanga (6.0, 76 minutes), Lewis Hall (6.0), and Joelinton (6.1, 75 minutes) all landed in the lower band of the ratings.
Even with slightly more of the ball and a similar number of corners (4-5), Newcastle rarely made Everton’s defensive work feel chaotic. Four Everton saves were required, but the visitors’ ability to keep Newcastle’s shots off target was the more telling detail.
Everton’s best players rose above the mess
In a match with plenty of average performances, Everton had clear stand-outs. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall posted the top match rating at 8.5 after completing 90 minutes, setting the tone for a display built on control and timely execution.
At the back, Jarrad Branthwaite delivered an 8.2 rating in 82 minutes, a strong hint of how well Everton coped with Newcastle’s shot count. And match-winner Barry matched that 8.2 in 80 minutes, turning Everton’s better chances into the only goal that mattered.
The stats back up the idea that Everton were more efficient rather than dominant: 48% possession, five corners, and nine fouls. But they produced the bigger xG and the greater accuracy, which is often the difference in tight away wins.
What it means, and what both sides must fix
The result shifts the table picture after Round 9. Everton move up to seventh on 13 points from nine matches, climbing from 11th. Newcastle slip to 13th on 11 points, dropping from eighth.
For Newcastle, the fix is clear: shot quality and composure. Seventeen attempts should not translate into just two on target, and the poorest ratings clustered around the attacking group. Everton, despite the win, will want to turn their edge in big chances and xG into more than a single goal, because games like this can swing on fine margins if the finishing dries up.
Written automatically by PLStats from our match data. How our pages are made.